Thanks for the responses so far. I've gone back and forth as to what I should do at this point. An ultimadum isn't going to solve the problem, only put more pressure on the marriage and I'm not the kind of person to say 'no' to much. I just want him to be more open. It bothers me most when he looks at it while I'm in the shower, or in the next room cooking dinner, or on his cell in the car on the way home (yes, I caught him in that, he had it pulled up on the internet browser on his phone when I went to look for a bookmark to a site he was telling me about). I want him to not hide it from me, to say "oh, I got this email today, check it out", or "let's watch some porn".
When he and I dated, we lived apart for the first 10 1/2 months. During that time, he would often forward me emails that contained pictures of naked women, and would forward him links to great porn videos I'd find online. I have NO problem with watching it, looking at naked pictures of women (or men, although he's not into THAT luckily, LOL), I have problems with it being hidden from me. If he was doing it in front of me, or including me in it, I wouldn't care, and I've told him this so many times I've lost count. It's so frustrating to feel like this.
He said he doesn't watch it to get excited or masturbate, he just likes it. He's been looking at it since he was a young teenager. He's been hiding it from his family, his ex-wife, ex-girlfriends, etc., but they were all against it. I'm pro-porn, yet he still hides it. He looks at it regularly, it used to be every day or so, now it's scaled back a little to once or twice a month (beyond Playboy), that I know of. Call me a horrible wife or whatever, but I do check up on him from time to time. If you're not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to hide, therefore should be open. He has all of my email and online account login information, I use the same username and password for almost everything, so it's not difficult to figure me out. I rarely clear my history on my computer or my phone, and never lock them because I don't do anything that I feel needs to be hidden. I'm open and honest, he knows that. He doesn't like when I snoop, but I'm just being a cautious wife. Men can be married to their wives for years, decades, then come to find out he's a closet bisexual/cheater who has been cheating on his wife with a coworker or friend or whatever for the entire marriage. I trust my husband to an extent, but I believe that you can never ever fully trust anyone.
But for now, my concern is that he refuses to minimize the collection he has, he looks at it regularly, he would probably freak out and throw a huge fit if I deleted all of it and got rid of everything... does that make him a porn addict? What are the conditions? He doesn't require it in order to perform intimately, he has a normal sex drive, he's never cheated on me physically (that I am aware of, but he's never given me the faintest feeling that he'd cheat on me), but he leads me to believe that porn is part of his life and he's not going to give it up. At 31 years old, isn't he past the whole "OMG BOOBIES" phase??? After looking at porn for 15+ years, isn't that enough? I mean, again, I don't mind the monthly Playboy, I enjoy it. I don't mind the occasional porn video online to get things stirred up or even get some ideas. But when he's looking at nude pictures or videos on a regular basis, when does that become an addiction?
Now, he does backup his hard drive on his computer, and it was done recently. I was actually thinking about deleting all of the porn on his computer, and hiding, make him think I got rid of every single thing. He said he'd choose me over porn, so in reality, he SHOULDN'T get mad at me... right?? LOL, I know this is a bit drastic, but he wouldn't lose any of it, and it would give me a little idea of what I'm dealing with here. If he was an addict, he'd immediately put the porn back on there and yell at me or whatever, right? If he wasn't, he wouldn't care either way? Like ARF said, there's plenty of it out there online, why would he need like 50 GB of porn saved to his computer?
One thing to note, when he and I started dating, he kept all of the pictures/videos on his phone under is iPod library and Photos. When I moved in and noticed he had that on his phone, I kinda made a deal of it. I told him that there was no sense in him walking around with 100+ videos and 500+ pictures of naked women on his phone, and he should take it all off of his phone. We argued a little bit, not bad, but he did take everything off his phone.
What should I do? Wipe out the porn, and see what happens? Or leave him be and try to talk to him about it again?
Thanks