Have you ever heard the phrase "paint yourself into a corner"? I actually did paint myself into a corner once. Literally. It's a thing that happens when you are painting a wooden or concrete floor. People who aren't thinking it through will generally start near the stairs or doorway that is their only exit. They diligently paint and paint, gradually moving backward to the rear-most part of the room. At some point, though, it dawns on them that the only way out of the room is across all of those square feet of still-wet paint. You're in the corner, you want to finish the floor and clean your paint brush, but you can't do that without ruining all of the hard work you've just completed. Your choices are to wait in your corner, trapped, until the pain dries. If you do that, the paint in your (still-open) paint can, and the paint on your brush, will also dry. You can't use the bathroom. Get a drink of water. You and everything you have will just dry up, shrink, and curl with dryness. Or, you walk across the fresh paint backward and try your best to cover up your footprints with fresh paint. But that never works, because the further you get toward the starting point, the more viscous and semi-dry the paint is already. Your footprints will remain in that paint forever, or at least until it becomes old and worn and it is time to re-paint the floor.
You should have been honest with your boyfriend/fiance about your past. I do not believe that a person should share his/her sexual history with every new date. However, there comes a point in a relationship that is moving toward serious commitment where it is incumbent upon partners to do this. In fact, it is critical. I always urge every couple getting serious enough to consider commitment to share sexual histories, for precisely the reason outlined in this thread. Sooner or later the history will come out. There may be things in one's sexual past that the partner cannot accept. It's best to figure that out early. Lies bloat and swell with time. The longer a lie lurks in the dark before being revealed, the larger it becomes.
Me, personally, if I were a young man considering proposing to a woman of quality whom I loved and clicked with, and she told me she had been an escort in her past, that would not impact my decision. There are a lot of men like me, who would commit to a woman who previously been a sex worker. And there are a lot of men for whom this would be a deal-breaker. If you are a woman who had been a sex worker, logic dictates that you'd want to be sure your man was in the former camp, not the latter, before yourself committing. Doing anything else is just dumb.
In your case, you have amplified the issues with your past by actively building a mythology with your fiance around your engagement: Christianity, purity, "saving" one's self for marriage. Personally I sneer at that concept, no matter who does it. What does "saving" one's self mean? Frottage, but no PIV intercourse? I'm aware that some self-described Christian girls engage in anal sex under this theory. What about masturbation? Erotic thoughts? Looking at porn? Wet dreams? Sexuality is a normal incident of adolescence and young adulthood. In general, "saving" one's self merely involves defining a synthetic boundary around a described subset of sexual activities (in my experience, usually it is limited to PIV intercourse) and agreeing that this handful of acts, out of the universe of all possible sexual acts, will not be shared together by this couple until after marriage. It's a goofy concept.
But I digress. You, my dear, are on the horns of a classic dilemma. Look up the concept of dilemma. Yours is a dilemma of your own creation. I honestly cannot believe you allowed this relationship to get to the point is has. Really poor judgment and decision-making. Your dilemma is especially large in size because of the nature of what you did in the "before" time vis-a-vis the synthetic construct that you and your fiance are choking down with respect to (the lack of) sex between the two of you now.
WWJD? I'll tell you what the J-Man would do: he'd tell the unvarnished truth. Be like J. Tell your man now, before you're married and it's too late.
I realize I may be wasting my breath. It appears that some or most of your replies have been deleted, but there are quotes from you in some of the other replies. Did you really say these things?
What I'm saying is that don't you agree that if we are married and have children, he'll be more reluctant to leave? We are both young. He'll get over it eventually.
Just think about who is hurting now. It's me. I'm the one carrying this burden while everyone else is happy. If I were to tell today, so many people would be hurt. If anything I'm protecting everyone. If I had some bad news to break to someone, it would be better to wait until the best possible moment. Don't you agree?
Nope. I don't agree. Not even a little. Lies grow with age. The above indicates an admixture of almost unfathomable naivete and profound self-interested dishonesty at the highest level. Fundamentally, you are a liar.
You guys are jumping on me calling be a prostitute but I'm far from that. I've changed. The Lord has forgiven me. You call me a liar but I'm simply delaying the truth. I'll tell him one day but the timing needs to be right.
To be clear, I'm not calling you a "prostitute", nor am I judging your worth as a woman. As I note, I personally would not have any issue committing to a woman who had been a sex worker at some stage of her life.
I realize that I do need to tell him at some point. I promise I will do that. I've just realized that it's better we wait until we are settled in our married so at least my husband would have something to lose if he decides to leave. I have to protect myself too. I've put too much into this relationship to walk away with nothing.
No, wait, I take that back. I am calling you a prostitute. "I've put too much into this relationship to walk away with nothing." Those words are the words of a *****. You are still approaching your relationship as a transactional exchange of consideration. Utterly despicable. I'm sorry I wasted my breath here.
I will close with this. Consider that the father-in-law to be is a fat disgusting pig with a flaccid weenie who cheats on his wife with sex workers. Consider that, in a lot of cases, the apple doesn't fall too far from the tree. Have you really educated yourself about the true deep-down character of the man you are thinking of marrying? Clearly, he does not know your true character. I think both of you are going into this with fantasies in your heads, denying your respective realities.